Three Different "Oscillation" Outcomes For Rose, Tiger and Padraig Harrington

Justin Rose finished his Players Championship with a fist pump after a rescinded two shot penalty following a ball "oscillation"...

Justin Rose finished his Players Championship with a fist pump after a rescinded two shot penalty following a ball "oscillation" incident in round three.

Rose was originally awarded the two shot penalty after viewing the incident in HD with referees following his round.




But as Tiger Woods fans will know, the rules about ball moving incidents not being visible to the naked eye were changed after his two shot penalty at Conway Farms.  Woods famously stormed out of the rules trailer after that incident, insisting he didn't see the ball move, and a short time later the rule was changed.



The rule change brought into force by  the R&A and USGA determined: "New Decision 18/4 provides that, where enhanced technological evidence (eg HDTV, digital recording or online visual media, etc.) shows that a ball has left its position and come to rest in another location, the ball will not be deemed to have moved if that movement was not reasonably discernible to the naked eye at the time."

In an interview after his final round Justin Rose said he read the ruling carefully on Saturday night and said "hey that sounds exactly like my situation."



If Rose was exonerated and Tiger Woods suffered a two shot penalty spare a thought for Padraig Harrington who was DQ'd in Abu Dhabi in 2011.  Under the rule change there would be no penalty and who knows, Padraig might be in a lot better place than he is now.

The Irishman's ball moved on a green as his hand brushed against it after replacement in front of his marker, an instance that was spotted by a television viewer.



Last word to the PGA Tour who issued this statement.

After further review of the 2-stroke penalty given to Justin Rose during the third round of THE PLAYERS Championship for a violation of Rule 18-2B and subsequent failure to replace the ball in the original place, the PGA TOUR Rules Committee has rescinded the penalty with Rose, who now enters the final round at 7-under-par. He will remain in his original pairing at 12:35 with Brian Stuard.

At the time of the review immediately following Rose’s round, in which Rose participated, it was thought that Decision 18/4 (Television Evidence Shows Ball at Rest Changed Position But by Amount Not Reasonably Discernible to Naked Eye) a copy of which is attached, was not applicable because the review of the footage shown in the telecast showed that the ball may have moved in a way that was discernable to the naked eye and when viewing the incident with Rose in the television compound, it was confirmed that the ball did in fact move very slightly.  Thus, at the time, the Rules Committee deemed that the ball had moved in a manner that was reasonably discernable to the naked eye. The Committee, therefore, assessed the general penalty under Rule 18 of two strokes.

Overnight, given the fact that Decision 18/4 had been implemented in January of 2014, yet had not been utilized in PGA TOUR competition, the Rules Committee reopened the incident and focused on how much the use of sophisticated technology played a part in making the original ruling. After that review, it was determined that the only way to confirm whether and how much the ball had in fact changed position, was to utilize sophisticated technology.

This morning, after consulting with the governing bodies and PGA TOUR Commissioner Tim Finchem, it was determined that without the use of sophisticated technology, it was not reasonably discernable to the naked eye that the ball had left its original position and had come to rest in its original place. Thus, the player’s determination that the ball had not moved was deemed to be conclusive and the penalty does not apply in this situation. Having reached this decision, the Committee immediately notified Rose and rescinded the 2-stroke penalty.

Decision 18/4: Television Evidence Shows Ball at Rest Changed Position But by Amount Not Reasonably Discernible to Naked Eye

Q.A player addresses his ball. He observes a slight motion of the ball but believes that it has only oscillated and has not left its original position. He therefore plays the ball as it lies. Later, the Committee becomes aware from television evidence that the ball had in fact left its position and come to rest in another place, although that change of position was such that it was not reasonably discernible to the naked eye at the time of the incident. What is the ruling?

A.The ball is deemed not to have moved and therefore there is no penalty under Rule 18-2b. The Definition of "Moved" – when a ball "leaves its position and comes to rest in any other place" – does not contemplate movements of the ball that are only discernible through the use of high definition television or any other form of sophisticated technology.

When determining whether or not his ball at rest has moved, a player must make that judgment based on all the information readily available to him at the time, so that he can determine whether the ball must be replaced under Rule 18-2b or another applicable Rule. When the player's ball has left its original position and come to rest in another place by an amount that was not reasonably discernible to the naked eye at the time, a player's determination that the ball has not moved will be deemed to be conclusive, even if that determination is later shown to be incorrect through the use of sophisticated technology.

On the other hand, if the Committee determines, based on all of the evidence it has available, that the ball changed its position by an amount that was reasonably discernible to the naked eye at the time, the ball is deemed to have moved. As the player did not replace the ball, he incurs a penalty under the applicable Rule and Rule 20-7c for playing from a wrong place.

These principles apply to any review of technological evidence by the Committee, whether before the player makes his next stroke or any time thereafter. These principles also apply in a situation in which the player made no determination whether or not his ball at rest moved (e.g., because he had walked away from his ball after addressing it, was not looking at his ball, or otherwise did not observe any motion of the ball or have any reason to believe that his ball might have moved).

COMMENTS

Name

2009 season golf highlights,1,2010 masters highlights,1,2010 us masters,2,2010 witb Ian Poulter,1,2013 funny,674,2013 Video,1029,2014 Volvo Golf Champions Betting Tips and Expert Picks,1,2024 Masters,1,3 irish open tips,1,3 irish open; spindoctor,2,430 metre par 3,1,accenture match play 2010 tips,1,Acushnet,1,Alvaro Quiros,1,Alvaro Quiros - konica minolta biz hub swing vision,1,Amendoeira Review,1,anders hansen witb,1,Andy Campbell,1,andy roberts,1,angel cabrera witb,1,anthony hopkins talks about the USPGA on Sky HD,1,anthony kim,1,Anthony Kim witb,1,Anthony Wall,1,Appleby,1,april fools golf,1,aqua-man,1,Arnold Palmer Invitaional and Andalucia Open Betting Tips,1,augusta,4,avantha masters 2010 final round highlights,1,avantha masters betting tips,1,baddeley,1,Ballantine's Championship Final Round Results,1,ballinrobe golf club,2,baltray,2,barack obama pic funny,1,ben curtis witb,1,Ben hogan,1,ben hogan full dvd torrent,6,Best golf tips,1,best golf torrents,6,bet,423,bet your balls,5,betfair,1,betfair ballentine's championship 2010 golf betting tips,1,betfair golf tips,1,betfair verizon heritage betting tips,1,betting,8,Betting Tips,63,bloggy underfoot the spindoctor's view,2,bmw international open tips,1,BMW PGA Championship 2010,1,BMW PGA Championship Tips,1,Bob Hope Classic Final Round Highlights 2010,1,Bob Menery,1,boo,2,boylesports golf tips,5,brent graham,1,british open 2010 qualifying,1,british open tips,1,Byron Nelson Tips,1,cabrera,1,Camillo Villegas,1,Camillo Villegas witb,1,Camilo Villegas Spiderman,1,canadian open,1,Castano,1,Castleknock Review,1,catalunya,1,cheap green fees,1,china open,1,Chris Wood witb,1,chuck couch,1,classic,2,cleveland niblick review,1,colonial betting tips,1,Course Review,7,crystal swing,1,Daniel Gendreau,1,danny willett,1,darren clarke,2,Darren Clarke and Lee Westwood Golf Clinic Video,1,darren clarke porsche,1,darren clarke taylormade setanta ryder cup oceanico faldo dc60 golf irish open,1,darren clarke what's in the bag,1,darren clarke witb,1,David Glynn,1,davis,1,day 4 highlights,1,dc60,1,derek murray,4,Dizzee Rascal,1,Donal Hughes,58,Donal+Hughes,23,Doonbeg,1,Dr,1,Dr and the Medic,11,draft kings,1,draft kngs,1,driving tips,4,dubai desert classic 2010,1,dubai desert classic betting preview,1,dubai world championship preview,1,Duelling Drivers,1,dustin,1,Dustin Johnson,3,each way betting,1,Each Way Golf Betting Picks,1,Eamonn Kenneally,1,edfors,1,equipment,10,Estes,1,Estoril Open Betting,2,european open betting tips,1,european Tour,1,european tour golf,2,European Tour golf betting tips,1,european tour golf tips,7,european tour highlights,1,european tour live scoring,1,european tour odds,1,European Tour: 2010 Abu Dhabi golf championship final round highlights,1,fail,1,faldo,1,film,1,final round,1,final round highlights,4,fitness,1,floyd,1,Footjoy,1,footjoy icons,1,foregolf,4,foregolf.ie,3,Forsyth,1,Fred Couples witb 2010,1,Free Golf,3,free setanta sports quiz,3,funny,829,Funny golf ad,7,funny golf news,1,funny golf pic,1,funny golf video,1,Funny pic,1,funny.,1,Fuuny,1,game improvement tip,3,gareth maybin,2,garia,1,Gary Boyd,1,Genesis Open,1,Genzon course review,1,golf,2,Golf Betting,20,Golf betting predictions,1,golf betting strategy,1,golf betting tips,12,golf central,1,golf channel,1,golf digest,1,Golf Funny,26,golf glider,1,Golf Humour,29,golf ireland,1,golf live event,1,Golf Morocco,1,golf odds,2,Golf Personality,14,golf predictions,5,golf shaft stiffness scale,1,Golf Tips,12,Golf Vacations Ireland,1,Golf+Funny,12,Golf+Humour,14,golfcentral daily facebook,2,golfcentraldaily,5,golfcentraldaily.com,1,Golfing Legend,3,graeme mcdowell witb,1,Happy Gilmore,1,harrington suit,1,Harrington Vs McIlroy,2,he drinks tequila,1,HIdeki,1,highlights,1,hoch,1,Hogan's 5 lessons,1,holly sonders,2,hot equipment,5,How it's made,3,humour,6,Ian poulter barclays singapore open,1,Ian Poulter Fun,1,ian poulter video,1,In the bag,10,Ireland,3,Irish amateur golf,1,Irish Examiner,52,irish examiner golf,1,irish examiner golf spindoctor,1,irish open,1,Irish senior's open 2010,1,Jack Nicklaus,1,Jack Nicklaus Video,1,JB Carr,1,Jim Nantz,1,Jimenezd,1,jimmy kimmel,1,joburg Open tips,1,Joe Carr,1,John Daly,1,John Patrick Daly,1,Johnny O'Shea,1,Jon Rahm,3,Jose Manuel Lara,1,K C,1,k club,2,K Club Ryder Cup Memories,1,K Club Smurfit Course Review,2,Kelan MacDonagh,1,kenny perry,2,kenny perry witb,1,kevin phelan,1,Killeen Castle,3,Killeen Castle Fourball Voucher,2,langer,1,lee valley betting preview,1,Lee Valley Scratch Cup,1,lee westwood witb,1,Legends Golf Resort,1,Lesson,2,letter to shane lowry,1,LIV Golf,2,Lorena ochoa,1,lough erne course review,2,Lough Erne Golf Resort,3,Louis Copeland,1,louis oosthuizen witb,1,Luke Donald,1,Luke Donald witb,1,madrid masters tips,1,make the putt bra,1,marcus fraser,1,mark brown,1,Markus Brier,1,Martin Greeves,1,Martin Kaymer,1,masters,9,Masters Champion,3,Masters Immelman,1,Masters of Their Universe,1,masters weather,1,matteo manassero,1,mcginley,1,mcgrane,1,memorial tips,1,mikael lundeberg,1,mizuno,1,monty,2,monty moobs,1,munster,1,must have golf gear,1,Natalie Gulbis Stretching,1,new nike tiger woods commercial with father,1,Niall Gorey_Irish Amateur witb 2010,1,nick watney witb,1,Nike,2,nike SQ Dymo2 str8-Fit Driver,1,nike tiger father,1,norman,1,northern trust open 2010 final round highlights,1,Oceanico Faldo Course,1,Oceanico O'Connor Course,1,Oceanico portugal golf holiday,1,Oceanico Review,1,olazabal,1,on the tour truck,9,open de espana,1,pablo martin,1,paddypower golf tips,5,Padraig Harrington,5,Padraig Harrington 2010 Masters Interview,1,Padraig Harrington Equipment Wilson Staff,1,Parody,115,Patrick Reed,1,Paul Cutler,1,Paul Dunne,1,Pebble Beach Pro Am 2010,1,pelz,1,pga,1,pga championship,1,pga show demo day,2,pga show demo day rory mcilroy donal hughes mike dobbyn irish examiner spindoctor,1,PGA Tou,1,PGA tour betting,3,pga tour highlights 2010,3,Phil Bonham,2,phil mickelson,1,Phil Mickelson vid,1,Phil Mickelson witb,1,Phoenix Open 2010,1,Platinum One,1,Portugal Masters Betting Tips,1,postmortem,1,poulter,1,premier-licensing,1,president's cup,1,Press conference,1,Pro V1,1,Pro V1x,1,prointhebag,1,qatar Masters 2010,1,Qatar Masters Golf 2010 betting tips,1,quail hollow,3,quail hollow betting tips 2010,1,R9 Driver,2,rbc heritage,1,retire,1,rex hoggard,1,Richard Green,1,richie ramsey controversial,1,Rick Veitch,2,ricky barnes funny,1,Rob Hogan,1,Robin Williams Golf Pure Comedy Gold,1,robocup,1,roe,1,ron sirak,1,rory leonard what's in the bag,1,rory leonard witb,1,Rory McIlroy,7,Rory McIlroy Konica Minolta Slow Mo Swing Vision,1,rory mcilroy witb,4,ross fisher witb,1,Rules of golf quiz,2,Ryder Cup,9,ryder cup team selection,2,Santa Sack Golf Christmas Present Ideas Donal Hughes Spindoctor Irish Examiner,1,satire,160,Seam Barry,1,secrets of the short game torrent,5,secrets of the short game torrent download,4,sergio,3,sergio garcia,2,sergio garcia witb,3,setanta golf,4,Seve,1,shaft skinz,2,Shane Lowry,4,Shell Houston Open,2,shell houston open 2010 final round highlights,1,shell houston open 2010 prediction,1,Shell Houston Open Betting,1,shingo,1,simon cowell on golf,1,simon dyson witb,1,skinz,1,sky sports golf,1,Solheim Cup,1,south africa,2,speedgolf,1,Spindoctor,29,Sppedgolf,1,srixon z star ball review,1,st jude classic tips,1,stack and tilt,1,stats,1,Stephen Riley,1,Stewart Cink witb,1,Storm,1,str8-fit driver,1,Stricker,1,stuart appleby witb,1,stunt,1,sungjae Im WITB,1,tailored shorts,3,the adare manor golf challenge,1,The Duel On the Lough,1,The Lough Erne Challenge,1,the masters,4,the open,1,The players championship,1,tiger,2,Tiger attack,1,tiger rubik cube,1,tiger vanity fair,1,Tiger Woods,16,Tiger Woods Bethpage 2002,1,Tiger Woods Caddyshack Video,1,tiger woods dvd torrent downlaod,8,tiger woods instruction dvd torrent,7,tiger woods isleworth espn interview with Tom Ronaldi March 21st 2010,1,tiger woods plate collection,1,tiger woods song,1,tiger woods spotted sex addiction clinic hattiesburg mississippi,1,tiger woods what's in the bag,1,tiger woods wii torrent,8,tiger woods wins british open,1,Tiger Woods witb,2,time to golf,1,Titleist,2,tom watson clinic,1,tommy fleetwood,1,tony q'aja,1,Top european tour tipster,1,Tour Truck,2,tour warp,1,tpi fitness,2,training aid,1,travelers championship tips,1,trevor immelman,2,Uro Club,1,us master betting results,1,us masters,2,US Masters 2010,2,US Masters 2010 Betting Preview,1,us masters 2010 green jacket awards,1,US masters betting post mortem,1,US Masters Golf 2010 Betting Tips,1,us open,6,us open blog,2,US PGA Champion 2010,1,us pga tour,1,us tour betting tips,2,uspga tour tips,2,Valderrama,1,valero texas open 2010 betting tips,1,valero texas open tips,1,verizon heritage,1,Video,1033,videom funny,1,Vijay,1,Vijay and Boo Ad,1,Vilamoura Golf,1,wales open tips,1,wayne o'callaghan golf,6,wayne's world of fitness,9,weird golf news,1,wells fargo,1,west of ireland golf 2010,1,westwood,1,westwood suit,1,wgc ca championship 2010 tips,1,what,2,what's in angel cabrera's bag,1,What's In Fred Couples Bag 2010,1,what's in lee westwood's bag,1,what's in peter lawrie's bag,1,what's in ross fisher's bag,1,what's in simon dyson's bag,1,what's in the bag,336,what's in the bag 2010 Charl Schwartzel,1,what's in the bag 2010 Cian Curley,1,What's In the Bag 2010 Fred Couples,1,what's in the bag 2010 Louis Oosthuizen,1,what's in the bag 2010 Matteo Manassero,1,what's in the bag 2010 Rhys Davies,1,What’s In The Bag 2010 Rickie Fowler,1,what's in the bag 2010 Y.E. Yang,1,what's in the bag angel cabrera,1,What's in the bag ernie els,1,what's in the bag Justin Rose,1,what's in the bag Kenny Perry,1,what's in the bag nick dougherty,1,what's in the bag Patrick Reed,1,what's in the bag Rory McIlory,4,what's in the bag ross fisher,1,what's in the bag simon dyson,1,what's in the bag stuart appleby,1,what's in the bag Tiger Woods,3,what'sin the bag,1,whats in the bag,61,winter golf special offers,1,witb,406,witb 2010 Ross Fisher,1,witb edoardo molinari 2010,1,witb Francesco Molinari 2010,1,witb Jim Furyk 2010,1,witb matt kuchar 2010,1,witb Peter Lawrie 2010,1,witb rory mcilroy 2010,1,witb rory mcilroy 2012,1,Women's British Open Awards,1,woody austin,1,Y.E. Yang,2,Yang's Hybrid,1,
ltr
item
GolfCentralDaily | Golf Parody Fun Gossip Jokes Betting Tips: Three Different "Oscillation" Outcomes For Rose, Tiger and Padraig Harrington
Three Different "Oscillation" Outcomes For Rose, Tiger and Padraig Harrington
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgPaIpz4ESzeBvnr72QcCfXVG1gkwfUfzxl54BhBm0eLs6TI7mz7YFVRTCnZ0FZfyJBlGCb_bEktGcCdFGL3yotMuVHdYxLNNAOiynM2Na6U9LB_g2QTlHWzQJ7vUXzYoWbTlNkQ3Nmcghv/s1600/Rose+ball.JPG
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgPaIpz4ESzeBvnr72QcCfXVG1gkwfUfzxl54BhBm0eLs6TI7mz7YFVRTCnZ0FZfyJBlGCb_bEktGcCdFGL3yotMuVHdYxLNNAOiynM2Na6U9LB_g2QTlHWzQJ7vUXzYoWbTlNkQ3Nmcghv/s72-c/Rose+ball.JPG
GolfCentralDaily | Golf Parody Fun Gossip Jokes Betting Tips
https://www.golfcentraldaily.com/2014/05/three-different-oscillation-outcomes.html
https://www.golfcentraldaily.com/
https://www.golfcentraldaily.com/
https://www.golfcentraldaily.com/2014/05/three-different-oscillation-outcomes.html
true
7321519672776175452
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content